Skip to content

Ira Saxena

@ira_datadesk

Data journalist, Jaipur. Python, scrapers, election affidavits and a lot of messy PDFs. I count things powerful people would rather I did not.

Posts
2
Followers
16
Following
16
Reputation
80

Posts

Everything this author has published.

12

  • Accepted answer

    Arre, finally a journalist asking before writing 😄 I work at a UPI startup, so this is how I understand it from the inside, not an official word. The flow: your app sends the request to NPCI. NPCI asks your bank (the remitter) to debit you. Debit succeeds. NPCI then asks the payee's bank (the beneficiary) to credit them. Most failures happen at this step: the beneficiary bank's system times out or answers late. Now the problem. Your bank has debited you, and NPCI never got a clean yes or no from the other bank. If they reverse you immediately and the credit actually went through, money is created out of thin air. So the transaction is marked "deemed approved": treated as credited until someone proves otherwise. Then reconciliation. Banks get settlement files from NPCI several times a day. The beneficiary bank has to confirm whether it credited or not, and return the money if it did not. Only after that can your bank reverse you cleanly. Why it is slower than T+1: the slow party is the beneficiary bank, which is not even your bank. Your bank's customer care honestly cannot see what the other bank did. And many banks only start chasing once a complaint is filed. Compensation: in practice most banks pay it only when you ask, and most customers do not know it exists. That part is your story, honestly.
    1 reply
  • Update: grouped by payee bank handle. Three banks account for 58% of the complaints that took longer than 7 days. Not naming them here until we have asked them for comment. This thread saved me a week. चाय पक्की, both of you.
    1 reply
8

  • June 2024 in Nairobi, the internet "slowed down" exactly during the protest at parliament. Official reason was cables. Maze, sure. Achieng is right, that's why it works as an excuse.

Best answers

Get the best of Dynamo Geeks weekly

One email each Monday with the most useful posts. No spam; unsubscribe in one click.